Substantial variation in surgical mortality rates and costs per surgical episode exists across providers, suggesting opportunities for improvement. While a variety of initiatives have been launched to enhance the safety, quality, and cost-efficiency of surgical care, these efforts focus almost exclusively on the surgeon's activities in the operating room and immediately afterward. However, there is growing recognition that coordination of care and communication among the surgeon, the referring primary care physician (PCP), and consultants are crucial. As such, optimizing surgical care will require the ability to measure and understand the care delivered by all physicians involved in the surgical episode and their interactions. In this context, the candidate (Dr. John M. Hollingsworth) seeks to characterize and evaluate the effectiveness of physician social networks that deliver surgical care. The candidate, a urologist and health services researcher at the University of Michigan, will leverage this proposal to broaden the scientific and clinical scope of his research agenda, and to facilitate his development into an independent investigator. During the period of support, he will pursue additional didactic instruction in several disciplines, including graduate- and doctoral-level courses in network theory, health economics, and healthcare organization and policy. He will also have ample opportunities for mentored, project-based learning, including the hands-on application of advanced statistical modeling and the techniques of social network analysis. The research plan has 3 Specific Aims.
Specific Aim 1 : To map physician social networks that deliver surgical care. With files from Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan and Michigan Medicare plans (2008-2010), the candidate will identify beneficiaries undergoing 1 of 4 common inpatient surgical procedures. By surgery type, he will use a validated method to graph physician social networks at hospitals where these procedures are performed, characterizing them in a number of directions across a range of local and global network properties. He hypothesizes that, compared with physician social networks serving rural areas, those at urban hospitals have a larger number of physicians, but their average distances are similar. He posits that physician social networks that care for female and black patients will be sparser than those for male and white patients, respectively.
Specific Aim 2 : To evaluate the effect of physician social networks on surgical care safety and quality. The candidate will then examine the association between physician connectedness and a hospital's safety culture/teamwork climate. He will also assess for a relationship between measures of surgical quality (i.e., operative mortality, readmissions, and postoperative complications) and local network properties across 3 phases of the surgical episode. He hypothesizes that networks in which the surgeon, referring PCP, and consultant tend to cluster together foster environments of safety. He posits that while surgeon centrality confers lower morbidity and mortality during the operative phase, greater surgeon-PCP tie strength leads to fewer complications and readmissions in the transition phase.
Specific Aim 3 : To examine the impact of physician social networks on the costs of surgical care. Finally, the candidate will quantify total expenditures for patients cared for by networks with varying levels of physician connectedness. He will explore specific sources of savings by comparing component payments over global network properties. He hypothesizes that significant variation in total episode expenditures exists between networks. He posits that cohesive and dense networks accrue savings from a variety of sources, including lower payments for post-acute care. Completion of the proposed research will inform the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services and other large payers on the extent to which strengthening interactions between physicians, in general, might impact on the safety, quality, and costs of surgical care. More broadly, findings from this proposal will provide researchers, clinician leaders, and policymakers with additional insight into the nature of relationships among different types of physicians and their importance for healthcare delivery.

Public Health Relevance

The proposed work will characterize physician social networks that deliver surgical care in the State of Michigan;it will also assess how patterns of connections among physicians in these networks relate to the safety, quality, and costs of surgical care that they provide. Since coordination of care and communication between providers are central to many reforms outlined in the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act of 2010, tools for measuring and monitoring physician connectedness will have obvious relevance to the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services and other large payers charged with implementation. More broadly, findings from this proposal will help researchers, clinician leaders, and policymakers understand the basis of optimal healthcare delivery systems.

Agency
National Institute of Health (NIH)
Type
Clinical Investigator Award (CIA) (K08)
Project #
5K08HS020927-03
Application #
8730124
Study Section
HSR Health Care Research Training SS (HCRT)
Program Officer
Anderson, Kay
Project Start
Project End
Budget Start
Budget End
Support Year
3
Fiscal Year
2014
Total Cost
Indirect Cost
Name
University of Michigan Ann Arbor
Department
Urology
Type
Schools of Medicine
DUNS #
City
Ann Arbor
State
MI
Country
United States
Zip Code
48109
Hollingsworth, John M; Birkmeyer, John D; Ye, Zaojun et al. (2014) Specialty-specific trends in the prevalence and distribution of outpatient surgery: implications for payment and delivery system reforms. Surg Innov 21:560-5
Hollingsworth, John M; Wilt, Timothy J (2014) Lower urinary tract symptoms in men. BMJ 349:g4474
Dauw, Casey A; Kaufman, Samuel R; Hollenbeck, Brent K et al. (2014) Expulsive therapy versus early endoscopic stone removal in patients with acute renal colic: a comparison of indirect costs. J Urol 191:673-7
Milose, Jaclyn C; Kaufman, Samuel R; Hollenbeck, Brent K et al. (2014) Prevalence of 24-hour urine collection in high risk stone formers. J Urol 191:376-80
Hollingsworth, John M; Rogers, Mary A M; Krein, Sarah L et al. (2013) Determining the noninfectious complications of indwelling urethral catheters: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Ann Intern Med 159:401-10
Hollingsworth, John M; Norton, Edward C; Kaufman, Samuel R et al. (2013) Medical expulsive therapy versus early endoscopic stone removal for acute renal colic: an instrumental variable analysis. J Urol 190:882-7
Sakshaug, Joseph W; Miller, David C; Hollenbeck, Brent K et al. (2013) Urologists and the patient centered medical home. J Urol 190:1345-9