In our previous work, we found evidence of large and persistent efficiency differences among healthcare providers - variations in both inputs (utilization) and outputs (risk-adjusted mortality). These studies were largely limited to cross-sectional analysis of the U.S. Medicare population, but we know much less about the dynamic process by which more or less efficient treatments diffuse across providers or regions over time. Nor do we understand the link between provider efficiency - whether costs or outcomes - and the degree of competition and pricing in the under-65 private-pay or Medicaid markets. Finally, how does provider efficiency in the U.S. compare to other countries - does the U.S. over-treat or do other countries ration care? On the question of dynamics, we first ask: given that health care costs have risen over time, was the money spent on efficient (cost-effective) or inefficient treatments? To address this question, we propose to examine specific conditions such as acute myocardial infarction (AMI) and cardiovascular disease in the Medicare population during 1998-2012, but extend the analysis to other disease. To quantify the idea of changes in efficiency, we develop an efficiency index for hospitals and physician-hospital networks and examine changes over time across regions in response to physician and market characteristics. Second, we focus on the interaction among Medicare, Medicaid, and (in Texas) Blue-Cross/Blue-Shield insurance claims, and how differences in prices, market power, and Medicaid payment policies could affect efficiency in their treatment of Medicare patients, whether through effects on quantities (substitution into Medicare when Medicaid pays little) or quality. Third, we compare efficiency between the U.S. and Canada, a country with fee-for-service reimbursement for physicians but global payments to hospitals. We first normalize prices for treatments to abstract from price differences across countries, and compare the distribution of our efficiency index across providers in both countries. Fourth, returning to U.S. data, we develop a new approach to estimating the relative importance of productive inefficiency (differences in hospital expertise holding costs constant) versus allocative inefficiency (treatments with marginal health benefits and poor cost-effectiveness). We use two data sources;(a) detailed chart review data for AMI patients, and (b) surgical quality in Michigan from Subproject 3.

Public Health Relevance

Formalizing and measuring sources of inefficiency in healthcare is the key to understanding whether (or why) some regions in the U.S. appear to be lagging behind others (or other countries) in providing high-quality low-cost care. Our project allows us to identify the location and correlates of inefficiency, and for specific clinical conditions, the precise type of inefficiency that exists.

National Institute of Health (NIH)
National Institute on Aging (NIA)
Research Program Projects (P01)
Project #
Application #
Study Section
Special Emphasis Panel (ZAG1-ZIJ-1)
Project Start
Project End
Budget Start
Budget End
Support Year
Fiscal Year
Total Cost
Indirect Cost
Dartmouth College
United States
Zip Code
Bekelis, Kimon; Gottlieb, Dan; Labropoulos, Nicos et al. (2017) The impact of hybrid neurosurgeons on the outcomes of endovascular coiling for unruptured cerebral aneurysms. J Neurosurg 126:29-35
Nyweide, David J; Bynum, Julie P W (2017) Relationship Between Continuity of Ambulatory Care and Risk of Emergency Department Episodes Among Older Adults. Ann Emerg Med 69:407-415.e3
Chandra, Amitabh; Frakes, Michael; Malani, Anup (2017) Challenges To Reducing Discrimination And Health Inequity Through Existing Civil Rights Laws. Health Aff (Millwood) 36:1041-1047
Bekelis, Kimon; Skinner, Jonathan; Gottlieb, Daniel et al. (2017) De-adoption and exnovation in the use of carotid revascularization: retrospective cohort study. BMJ 359:j4695
Bekelis, Kimon; Gottlieb, Daniel J; Su, Yin et al. (2017) Comparison of clipping and coiling in elderly patients with unruptured cerebral aneurysms. J Neurosurg 126:811-818
Bekelis, Kimon; Missios, Symeon; MacKenzie, Todd A et al. (2017) Does Objective Quality of Physicians Correlate with Patient Satisfaction Measured by Hospital Compare Metrics in New York State? World Neurosurg 103:852-858.e1
Bekelis, Kimon; Missios, Symeon; Coy, Shannon et al. (2017) Association of Hospital Teaching Status with Neurosurgical Outcomes: An Instrumental Variable Analysis. World Neurosurg :
Norton, Edward C; Li, Jun; Das, Anup et al. (2017) Moneyball in Medicare. J Health Econ :
Regenbogen, Scott E; Cain-Nielsen, Anne H; Norton, Edward C et al. (2017) Costs and Consequences of Early Hospital Discharge After Major Inpatient Surgery in Older Adults. JAMA Surg 152:e170123
Missios, Symeon; Bekelis, Kimon (2017) Association of Hospitalization for Neurosurgical Operations in Magnet Hospitals With Mortality and Length of Stay. Neurosurgery :

Showing the most recent 10 out of 239 publications