B cell antibody responses are triggered by the binding of antigen to the clonally distributed B cell antigen receptors (BCRs). Over the last several years a great deal has been learned about the biochemistry of the complex signal cascades triggered by BCR antigen engagement. However, what remains relatively poorly understood are the molecular events that trigger the initiation of signaling. These events are likely to occur within seconds of antigen binding to the BCR and to be highly dynamic, involving many weak protein-protein and protein-lipid interactions. In general, the biochemical approaches that have been used so effectively to describe the BCR signaling pathways are inadequate to capture events that occur as rapidly and as transiently as those predicted to initiate BCR signaling. In addition, antigen binding to the B cell involves a dramatic spatial change in the BCRs resulting in their patching and capping and the formation of an immune synapse. All this potentially important spatial information is lost with the addition of detergents to cells for biochemical analyses. Consequently we have taken advantage of new live cell imaging technologies that allow analyses of the BCR and components of the BCR signaling pathway with the temporal and spatial resolution necessary to view the earliest events in B cell activation at the single molecule level without the complications that the addition of detergents introduce. Using live cell imaging, we showed that in B cells responding to antigen presented on a planar lipid bilayer, simulating an antigen presenting cell, BCRs form signaling active microclusters by a mechanism that does not require physical crosslinking of BCRs by multivalent antigens. We observed that in response to either monovalent or multivalent antigens the BCRs accumulate and form microclusters at the initial points of contact of the B cell membrane with the bilayer. Clustering did not depend on the ability of the BCR to signal subsequently, revealing clustering to be an intrinsic property of the BCRs. The microclusters grew by trapping mobile BCRs and the larger clusters were actively organized into an immune synapse. The kinetics of these events and signaling were identical for monovalent and multivalent antigens. We determined that the membrane-proximal ecto-domain of the BCR mIg was both necessary and sufficient for BCR oligomerization and signaling. BCRs that contained a mIg in which Cmu4 was deleted failed to cluster and to signal when engaging monovalent antigen. Conversely, Cmu4 expressed alone on the B cell surface spontaneously clustered and activated B cells. These findings lead us to propose a novel mechanism by which BCRs form signaling active microclusters that we termed the conformation induced oligomerization model for the initiation of BCR signaling. According to our model BCR in the resting state are not in an oligomerization receptive conformation such that random bumping has no repercussion. The binding of antigen on an opposing membrane exerts a force on the BCR to bring it into an oligomerization receptive form so that when two antigen-bound BCRs bump they oligomerize. Using the same live cell imaging technologies we approached a fundamental question in B cell biology namely what advantage is conferred on B cell activation by high affinity, isotype switched BCRs such as those expressed by memory B cells. We demonstrated that high affinity BCRs, as compared to low affinity BCR form immobile, signaling active BCR clusters more efficiently providing evidence that affinity discrimination is a BCR intrinsic function. We also determined that as compared to mIgM-containing BCRs, mIgG BCRs more efficiently form signaling active BCR microclusters in both mouse and human B cells. These results are important in providing a molecular understanding of the functional advantage of high affinity, isotype-switched BCRs. Over the last year we mapped the functional difference between IgG and IgM BCRs to the highly conserved 15 membrane proximal region of the mIgG cytoplasmic tail that contained a PDZ-binding motif. We showed that this region associated with the PDZ-domain containing synapse associated protein 97 (SAP97), a member of the membrane associated guanylate kinase family of scaffolding molecules that play key roles in controlling receptor density and signal strength at neuronal synapses. SAP97 accumulated and bound to IgG BCRs in the immune synapses that formed in B cells in response to antigen engagement. Deletion of SAP97 in IgG-expressing B cells by RNA interference or by targeted gene knocking out in SAP97-KO mice impaired immune synapse formation and the initiation of BCR signaling. This finding is important in showing that the enhanced response of memory B cells is encoded, in part, by a mechanism that involves SAP97 serving as a scaffolding protein in the IgG BCR immune synapse. Studies are in progress to determine if SAP97 plays a role in the generation and maintenance of B cell memory in vivo. To do so we have generated mice in which SAP97 expression is knocked down in the B cell lineage (SAP97 flox/CD19 cre mice) or in B cells participating in germinal center (GC) reactions (SAP97 flox/AID cre mice). These mice have been immunized and the Ab response in terms of the magnitude, kinetics of appearance, isotype and affinity of the resulting Ab are being analyzed. Because of the paucity of memory B cells in mice, our studies of IgM versus IgG BCRs in mouse B cells was limited either to transfected cell lines or in naive B cells and in B cells that had been induced to switch to IgG in vitro. Over the last year we extended our live cell imaging studies to describe the behavior of BCRs on human peripheral blood naive IgM-expressing B cells and IgG-expressing memory B cells in both resting cells and cells in which the BCR was activated. For the most part the behavior of human IgM BCRs on naive B cells and IgG BCRs on memory B cells recapitulated the behavior we observed for mouse B cells expressing IgM and IgG in that human IgG BCRs oligomerized more rapidly and to greater extent as compared to IgM BCRs. However, one novel observation was that in the resting state a larger portion of IgG BCRs appeared to be immobilized and associated with phosphorylated PI3K. This observation suggests that memory B cells may be primed to respond to antigen. To pursue this possibility we set out to determine the organization of the BCR on resting naive B cells and on memory B cells. Current evidence indicates that it is likely that BCRs are not randomly distributed on the B cell surface but rather confined to areas that define their interactions with both positive and negative regulating coreceptors. Such confinement could result in the relative immobility of the IgG BCRs on memory B cells and their association with activated PI3K. The organization of receptors on the B cell surface can be determined through super-resolution fluorescence imaging that allows the localization of single molecules. Over the last year we established super high resolution imaging (STORM) to describe, at the 10-50 nm level, the organization of the BCR in resting naive and memory B cells and in B cells in which the BCR is ligated. Our preliminary data indicate that most BCRs exist as monomers or dimers in both naive and memory B cells without an obvious organization. Following crosslinking the BCRs form large patches but within these patches the BCRs are mostly dimers suggesting that the primary signaling unit is a dimer rather than larger oligomer structures and that signaling is somehow amplified by the proximity of these dimers. In order to better understand the molecular mechanisms at play in the initiation of BCR signaling we began a collaboration with Dr. Raychaudhuri (UC Davis), a mathematical modeler.
|Xu, Yinsheng; Xu, Liling; Zhao, Meng et al. (2014) No receptor stands alone: IgG B-cell receptor intrinsic and extrinsic mechanisms contribute to antibody memory. Cell Res 24:651-64|
|Tolar, Pavel; Hanna, Joseph; Krueger, Peter D et al. (2009) The constant region of the membrane immunoglobulin mediates B cell-receptor clustering and signaling in response to membrane antigens. Immunity 30:44-55|
|Tolar, Pavel; Pierce, Susan K (2009) Change we can believe in--of the conformational type. Workshop on the Initiation of Antigen Receptor Signaling. EMBO Rep 10:331-6|
|Tolar, Pavel; Sohn, Hae Won; Pierce, Susan K (2008) Viewing the antigen-induced initiation of B-cell activation in living cells. Immunol Rev 221:64-76|
|Sohn, Hae Won; Tolar, Pavel; Pierce, Susan K (2008) Membrane heterogeneities in the formation of B cell receptor-Lyn kinase microclusters and the immune synapse. J Cell Biol 182:367-79|
|Sohn, Hae Won; Pierce, Susan K; Tzeng, Shiang-Jong (2008) Live cell imaging reveals that the inhibitory FcgammaRIIB destabilizes B cell receptor membrane-lipid interactions and blocks immune synapse formation. J Immunol 180:793-9|