Recent organizational changes, such as the increased emphasis on standardized procedures, in both the US and UK health care systems are likely to affect physicians' clinical decision making behavior (e.g., diagnoses, test-ordering, treatment). Older patients are more likely to experience the effects of these organizational changes due to the complexity and chronicity of the health problems that often accompany old age. This study will compare the clinical decision making patterns of physicians in the US health care system with their counterparts in the nationalized UK health care system, when presented with identical clinical information. This research by an experienced multidisciplinary international team builds on earlier successful work and proposes a factorial experiment to estimate simultaneously the relative influence of physician factors (clinical autonomy, gender, number of years since graduating medical school) and patient factors (age, gender, race and socioeconomic status) on the diagnosis and management of CHD and depression. Two hundred fifty-six physicians (128 in the US and 128 in the UK) will view two videotaped simulations of patients aged 55 and aged 75 consulting a primary care physician and presenting with either CHD or depression. The proposed experimental method, whose feasibility has been thoroughly demonstrated in prior studies, will identify and estimate both main and interactive effects among system, physician, and patient variables. Using 'think aloud' methodology to identify patterns of diagnostic considerations will allow estimation of physicians' cognitive processes underlying their decision-making in diagnosis and management of these two highly prevalent conditions. Generalizability of the findings is enhanced by focusing on two realistic clinical situations, and by randomly sampling and recruiting from physicians in primary care. The proposed study addresses a novel hypothesis - that international differences in disease largely result from variability in decision making (rather that geographic differences in disease associated with genetic background and life styles).

Agency
National Institute of Health (NIH)
Institute
National Institute on Aging (NIA)
Type
Research Project (R01)
Project #
5R01AG016747-02
Application #
6372338
Study Section
Health Systems Research (HSR)
Program Officer
Stahl, Sidney M
Project Start
2000-06-01
Project End
2003-05-31
Budget Start
2001-06-01
Budget End
2002-05-31
Support Year
2
Fiscal Year
2001
Total Cost
$432,904
Indirect Cost
Name
New England Research Institute
Department
Type
DUNS #
153914080
City
Watertown
State
MA
Country
United States
Zip Code
02472
Adams, A; Vail, L; Buckingham, C D et al. (2014) Investigating the influence of African American and African Caribbean race on primary care doctors' decision making about depression. Soc Sci Med 116:161-8
von dem Knesebeck, Olaf; Hoehne, Anke; Link, Carol et al. (2012) Talking about smoking in primary care medical practice--results of experimental studies from the US, UK and Germany. Patient Educ Couns 89:51-6
Shackelton-Piccolo, Rebecca; McKinlay, John B; Marceau, Lisa D et al. (2011) Differences between internists and family practitioners in the diagnosis and management of the same patient with coronary heart disease. Med Care Res Rev 68:650-66
Knesebeck, Olaf von dem; Bönte, Markus; Siegrist, Johannes et al. (2010) [Diagnosis and therapy of depression in the elderly--influence of patient and physician characteristics]. Psychother Psychosom Med Psychol 60:98-103
Siegrist, Johannes; Shackelton, Rebecca; Link, Carol et al. (2010) Work stress of primary care physicians in the US, UK and German health care systems. Soc Sci Med 71:298-304
Konrad, Thomas R; Link, Carol L; Shackelton, Rebecca J et al. (2010) It's about time: physicians' perceptions of time constraints in primary care medical practice in three national healthcare systems. Med Care 48:95-100
Lutfey, Karen E; Link, Carol L; Marceau, Lisa D et al. (2009) Diagnostic certainty as a source of medical practice variation in coronary heart disease: results from a cross-national experiment of clinical decision making. Med Decis Making 29:606-18
Maserejian, Nancy N; Link, Carol L; Lutfey, Karen L et al. (2009) Disparities in physicians' interpretations of heart disease symptoms by patient gender: results of a video vignette factorial experiment. J Womens Health (Larchmt) 18:1661-7
Lutfey, Karen E; Link, Carol L; Grant, Richard W et al. (2009) Is certainty more important than diagnosis for understanding race and gender disparities?: an experiment using coronary heart disease and depression case vignettes. Health Policy 89:279-87
von dem Knesebeck, Olaf; Bonte, Markus; Siegrist, Johannes et al. (2008) Country differences in the diagnosis and management of coronary heart disease - a comparison between the US, the UK and Germany. BMC Health Serv Res 8:198

Showing the most recent 10 out of 17 publications