This research examines the effect of microcomputer-based decision support systems (DSS) on the clinical reasoning of potential users, using QMR and ILIAD as test systems. Two issues are the primary focus: (1) the extent to which users modify their diagnostic opinions and workup plans as a result of interaction with the DSS and (2) the effects of clinical experience upon interaction with the DSS and the resulting consultations. Case materials will be selected and abstracted from those admitted for diagnostic evaluation on the Medicine services of three collaborating medical centers and will be presented to subjects for diagnostic assessment and workup planning, first without and then with the aid of a DSS. The study examines the effects of three independent variables (level of clinical experience, time of case work-up [pre- or post- consultation] and case cluster) on seven dependent variables: selection of relevant information for input into the DSS, user's diagnostic accuracy, confidence of the user in the diagnosis, cost and appropriateness of the planned next steps, diagnostic volatility, and system's diagnostic accuracy. 36 cases will be used, assigned to 4 clusters; all cases will have diagnoses in the knowledge base of two decision support systems. The subjects will be fourth-year medical students, second-year residents in internal medicine, and experienced general internists. By studying how consultations with computer-based DSSs are utilized by and affect the reasoning of clinicians with varying levels of clinical experience, this research contributes to understanding the role of decision support systems in improving diagnostic reasoning and clinical care, identifying how much clinical experience is needed to use them effectively, and assessing their potential for reducing unnecessary and expensive diagnostic procedures.

Agency
National Institute of Health (NIH)
Institute
National Library of Medicine (NLM)
Type
Research Project (R01)
Project #
3R01LM005630-04S1
Application #
2657007
Study Section
Biomedical Library and Informatics Review Committee (BLR)
Program Officer
Bean, Carol A
Project Start
1993-09-01
Project End
1999-08-31
Budget Start
1997-09-30
Budget End
1999-08-31
Support Year
4
Fiscal Year
1997
Total Cost
Indirect Cost
Name
University of Illinois at Chicago
Department
Internal Medicine/Medicine
Type
Schools of Medicine
DUNS #
121911077
City
Chicago
State
IL
Country
United States
Zip Code
60612
Friedman, Charles P; Gatti, Guido G; Franz, Timothy M et al. (2005) Do physicians know when their diagnoses are correct? Implications for decision support and error reduction. J Gen Intern Med 20:334-9
Hasnain, Memoona; Onishi, Hirotaka; Elstein, Arthur S (2004) Inter-rater agreement in judging errors in diagnostic reasoning. Med Educ 38:609-16
Friedman, Charles P; Gatti, Guido G; Murphy, Gwendolyn C et al. (2002) Exploring the boundaries of plausibility: empirical study of a key problem in the design of computer-based clinical simulations. Proc AMIA Symp :275-9
Elstein, Arthur S; Schwarz, Alan (2002) Clinical problem solving and diagnostic decision making: selective review of the cognitive literature. BMJ 324:729-32
Friedman, C; Gatti, G; Elstein, A et al. (2001) Are clinicians correct when they believe they are correct? Implications for medical decision support. Medinfo 10:454-8
Friedman, C P; Elstein, A S; Wolf, F M et al. (1999) Enhancement of clinicians' diagnostic reasoning by computer-based consultation: a multisite study of 2 systems. JAMA 282:1851-6
Friedman, C; Elstein, A; Wolf, F et al. (1998) Measuring the quality of diagnostic hypothesis sets for studies of decision support. Medinfo 9 Pt 2:864-8
Wolf, F M; Friedman, C P; Elstein, A S et al. (1997) Changes in diagnostic decision-making after a computerized decision support consultation based on perceptions of need and helpfulness: a preliminary report. Proc AMIA Annu Fall Symp :263-7
Elstein, A S; Friedman, C P; Wolf, F M et al. (1996) Effects of a decision support system on the diagnostic accuracy of users: a preliminary report. J Am Med Inform Assoc 3:422-8