Off-label prescription of drugs is a routine practice among physicians. The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) approves new drugs based on their effectiveness for a particular indication, but once a drug enters the market, physicians can prescribe drugs for other indications that they deem appropriate. Sometimes, such prescribing is based on rigorous randomized trial data that has not (yet) led to formal FDA approval for a given indication;other off-label use is based on less well-established evidence. Because of concerns about cost and/or quality of care, payors in both the private and public sectors have sought to prohibit off-label use, limit its coverage, and/or require patients to assume an increasing fraction of its cost. Off-label drug use thus involves prescriptions that may or may not be sound therapy, that may involve unnecessary risk to patients, and that may be cost-effective or cost-ineffective-or a mix of all three. Though off-label use has been estimated to account for nearly three-quarters of the use of some drugs, the practice remains poorly understood. Few studies have detailed extent to which newly approved drugs are prescribed for off-label uses, or the evidence supporting such utilization. In addition, scant data exist regarding the patient or physician or drug characteristics that predict when an off-label use is more likely to occur. Though promotion of drugs for off-label uses is strictly regulated, there have been several recent high-profile instances of violation of these regulations. No studies have systematically evaluated the impact of marketing or other legal, regulatory, or financial forces on the practice of off-label drug use. We propose to develop a comprehensive scheme for studying off-label drug use to categorize the different types of off-label use and their clinical, economic, and policy implications. We will apply this typology to evaluate the frequency and patterns of off-label drug use in three important categories: oncology drugs, neuropsychiatric drugs, and drugs for other rare diseases. We will identify target drugs and review the medical literature, as well as expert opinion, regarding specific uses of each product to define the quality of evidence supporting each off-label use. We will then evaluate the characteristics of off-label drug use in large population databases of prescriptions and diagnoses, including Medicaid patients, Medicare patients, and those covered by a large health insurer. Using these datasets, we will use multivariable regression to determine predictors of use of specific off-label drugs for particular purposes, and identify characteristics of patients, physicians, and medications that are associated with off-label use. Finally, we will use time-trend analysis to determine the impact of changes in legal, regulatory, or financial factors that impact off-label use. A better understanding of the properties and predictors of off-label use can inform evidence-based prescribing of these products. Studying the benefit-risk-cost relationships associated with such uses can lead to more enlightened approaches to prescribing and policy decisions in this increasingly contentious area.

Public Health Relevance

Many physicians prescribe drugs for non-FDA-approved reasons (off-label uses), but when this practice occurs without sufficient evidence basis, it raises important health policy concerns about patient safety and cost-effectiveness. We propose to study the characteristics of off-label drug use in three select classes-cancer drugs, neuropsychiatry drugs, and drugs for other rare diseases. Using expert interviews and pharmaceutical claims data from a variety of large databases, we will identify the predictors and frequency of off- label use and determine how the practice is affected by certain external scientific, market, and regulatory events.

Agency
National Institute of Health (NIH)
Institute
Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ)
Type
Clinical Investigator Award (CIA) (K08)
Project #
5K08HS018465-04
Application #
8281337
Study Section
HSR Health Care Research Training SS (HCRT)
Program Officer
Anderson, Kay
Project Start
2009-09-30
Project End
2014-07-31
Budget Start
2012-08-01
Budget End
2013-07-31
Support Year
4
Fiscal Year
2012
Total Cost
Indirect Cost
Name
Brigham and Women's Hospital
Department
Type
DUNS #
030811269
City
Boston
State
MA
Country
United States
Zip Code
02115
Kesselheim, Aaron S; Xu, Shuai; Avorn, Jerry (2014) Clinicians' contributions to the development of coronary artery stents: a qualitative study of transformative device innovation. PLoS One 9:e88664
Kesselheim, Aaron S; Tan, Yongtian Tina; Darrow, Jonathan J et al. (2014) Existing FDA pathways have potential to ensure early access to, and appropriate use of, specialty drugs. Health Aff (Millwood) 33:1770-8
Hwang, Thomas J; Avorn, Jerry; Carpenter, Daniel et al. (2014) Quantifying The Food And Drug Administration's rulemaking delays highlights the need for transparency. Health Aff (Millwood) 33:309-15
Austad, Kirsten E; Avorn, Jerry; Franklin, Jessica M et al. (2014) Association of marketing interactions with medical trainees' knowledge about evidence-based prescribing: results from a national survey. JAMA Intern Med 174:1283-90
Yeh, James S; Austad, Kirsten E; Franklin, Jessica M et al. (2014) Association of medical students' reports of interactions with the pharmaceutical and medical device industries and medical school policies and characteristics: a cross-sectional study. PLoS Med 11:e1001743
Kramer, Daniel B; Tan, Yongtian T; Sato, Chiaki et al. (2014) Ensuring medical device effectiveness and safety: a cross--national comparison of approaches to regulation. Food Drug Law J 69:1-23, i
Kesselheim, A S; Shiu, N (2014) The evolving role of biomarker patents in personalized medicine. Clin Pharmacol Ther 95:127-9
Rome, Benjamin N; Kramer, Daniel B; Kesselheim, Aaron S (2014) FDA approval of cardiac implantable electronic devices via original and supplement premarket approval pathways, 1979-2012. JAMA 311:385-91
Checchi, Kyle D; Huybrechts, Krista F; Avorn, Jerry et al. (2014) Electronic medication packaging devices and medication adherence: a systematic review. JAMA 312:1237-47
Hwang, Thomas J; Kesselheim, Aaron S; Bourgeois, Florence T (2014) Postmarketing trials and pediatric device approvals. Pediatrics 133:e1197-202

Showing the most recent 10 out of 46 publications