Tomosynthesis of breast imaging procedures (DBT) has been investigated for several years as related to the possible use of this technology in screening for the early detection of breast cancer. Recently, a Food and Drug Administration (FDA) panel voted to strongly recommend approval for the clinical use of tomosynthesis in the United States. The fact is that, to date, all demonstrated possible benefits of tomosynthesis have been tested under conditions that apply to a small fraction of screened women, namely those without prior studies available for comparison, simulating the interpretation of baseline mammograms in the laboratory. The largest benefit demonstrated to date in this context is the possibility of substantially and significantly reducing recall rates, with some indications that observer performance in detecting specific "mass like" abnormalities could also be improved, albeit to a lesser extent. There are no data regarding the possible impact, if any, of tomosynthesis for women who have repeat screening mammograms;hence, a prior examination is available for comparison during the screening interpretation. This group constitutes the majority of screened women (60%-90% depending on the practice) and their recall rates are lower by approximately a factor of 1.5 to 2 as compared with baseline recall rates. As important, determining change (or no change) from prior observations (examinations) raises radiologists'confidence levels regarding their recommendations. DBT in combination with full field digital mammography (FFDM), which is the practice as presented for consideration before the recent FDA panel, requires approximately doubling the radiation dose. Before we unilaterally implement DBT in the screening environment, we need to assess the possible benefits of DBT when a prior examination is available during the interpretation. This is the very purpose of this study. To do so we propose to perform an observer performance study when prior FFDM examinations are available to the interpreter.

Public Health Relevance

DBT in combination with FFDM is likely to be implemented in a large number of sites. As recommended for approval, it will require doubling the radiation dose to the examined breast because it has been tested in a unique population representing but a small fraction of screened women. This study will enable an assessment of the possible benefits of DBT when a prior examination is available to the interpreter.

Agency
National Institute of Health (NIH)
Institute
National Cancer Institute (NCI)
Type
Research Project (R01)
Project #
1R01CA163300-01
Application #
8214884
Study Section
Special Emphasis Panel (ZRG1-DTCS-U (81))
Program Officer
Baker, Houston
Project Start
2012-03-06
Project End
2015-02-28
Budget Start
2012-03-06
Budget End
2013-02-28
Support Year
1
Fiscal Year
2012
Total Cost
$230,659
Indirect Cost
$78,409
Name
University of Pittsburgh
Department
Radiation-Diagnostic/Oncology
Type
Schools of Medicine
DUNS #
004514360
City
Pittsburgh
State
PA
Country
United States
Zip Code
15213
Hakim, Christiane M; Anello, Marie I; Cohen, Cathy S et al. (2014) Impact of and interaction between the availability of prior examinations and DBT on the interpretation of negative and benign mammograms. Acad Radiol 21:445-9
Zuley, Margarita L; Bandos, Andriy I; Ganott, Marie A et al. (2013) Digital breast tomosynthesis versus supplemental diagnostic mammographic views for evaluation of noncalcified breast lesions. Radiology 266:89-95