There is broad agreement that the United States must slow rising health care costs, yet relatively little consensus about how best achieve it. This proposal aims to evaluate a policy experiment in the Oregon Medicaid program, using the Colorado Medicaid program as a control state. Colorado and Oregon have developed parallel programs that reflect the national movement toward accountable care and primary care medical homes. However, Oregon differs from Colorado in two significant ways. First, savings in Oregon's CCOs are enforced with a transition to a global budget that includes a large (11%) reduction in spending in their first year. Second, whereas Colorado continues fee-for-service (FFS) payments for specialists and carved-out behavioral health care, Oregon's program integrates funding and payment for behavioral and physical health care, including funds that have traditionally been """"""""carved out"""""""" for mental health and addiction treatment. CCOs have flexibility in how these dollars are spent. We will assess two key economic questions that are relevant to public and private payers across all states. First, faced with a large, exogenous decrease in funding, how are savings accomplished? Is it primarily through reductions in payment rates, or is it through an incentive to integrate delivery to realize efficient utilization patterns? Second, what are the consequences of financial integration of behavioral health? A preponderance of research has demonstrated that integrated primary care and behavioral health care can improve quality, but relatively little is known about how the methods of financing impact the degree of coordination and its effectiveness. Our study is specifically designed to decouple the specific impacts of spending reductions and financial integration from the contemporaneous policy changes (such as reliance on the medical home) that are occurring in both Oregon and Colorado. The proposed research will provide crucial knowledge for the development and design of innovations necessary to improve the long term value and affordability of health care.

Public Health Relevance

Our study evaluates the effects of major Medicaid program restructuring in Oregon, using Colorado as a control state. This study will provide early and critical information on policy approaches currently under consideration for Medicaid and Medicare programs - how to reduce health care spending (e.g., through reductions in unnecessary care, or through reductions in payment rates), and the implications of financial bundling of physical and mental health care.

National Institute of Health (NIH)
National Institute of Mental Health (NIMH)
Research Project (R01)
Project #
Application #
Study Section
Special Emphasis Panel (ZRG1-HDM-R (52))
Program Officer
Rupp, Agnes
Project Start
Project End
Budget Start
Budget End
Support Year
Fiscal Year
Total Cost
Indirect Cost
Oregon Health and Science University
Emergency Medicine
Schools of Medicine
United States
Zip Code
McConnell, K John (2016) Oregon's Medicaid Coordinated Care Organizations. JAMA 315:869-70
Mendelson, Aaron; Goldberg, Bruce; McConnell, K John (2016) New rules for Medicaid managed care - Do they undermine payment reform? Healthc (Amst) 4:274-276
Kim, Hyunjee; Hartung, Daniel M; Jacob, Reside L et al. (2016) The Concentration of Opioid Prescriptions by Providers and Among Patients in the Oregon Medicaid Program. Psychiatr Serv 67:397-404
Charlesworth, Christina J; Meath, Thomas H A; Schwartz, Aaron L et al. (2016) Comparison of Low-Value Care in Medicaid vs Commercially Insured Populations. JAMA Intern Med 176:998-1004
Alanis-Hirsch, Kelly; Croff, Raina; Ford 2nd, James H et al. (2016) Extended-Release Naltrexone: A Qualitative Analysis of Barriers to Routine Use. J Subst Abuse Treat 62:68-73
Chang, Anna Marie; Cohen, Deborah J; McCarty, Dennis et al. (2015) Oregon's medicaid transformation -- observations on organizational structure and strategy. J Health Polit Policy Law 40:257-64
McConnell, K John; Chang, Anna Marie; Cohen, Deborah J et al. (2014) Oregon's Medicaid Transformation: An Innovative Approach To Holding A Health System Accountable For Spending Growth. Healthc (Amst) 2:163-167
McCarty, Dennis (2013) Parity: an ongoing challenge and research opportunity. Am J Psychiatry 170:140-2