The goal of secondary prevention is to detect and treat a disease at its pre-clinical stage so as to prevent significant mortality or morbidity associated with late-stage disease. The benefit of secondary prevention can only be achieved if patients receive effective treatment following the diagnosis of a disease. Therefore, a discussion of the cost-effectiveness of secondary prevention strategies shall take into consideration the treatment aspect of a disease. Such consideration is also important for resource allocation because the cumulative cost of secondary prevention to the health care system can be substantial due to the large population involved in a screening intervention and the repetitive nature of screening exams over time. Our proposed study will explore the economics of secondary prevention by examining the association between the diffusion of treatment technologies and the cost-effectiveness of secondary prevention. Using screening mammography for women age 65 as an example, we will explore the above association and estimate the impact of various screening strategies on Medicare expenditures under different scenarios of treatment dissemination. Screening mammography strategies to be evaluated will consist of a combination of difference screening intervals (annual, biennial, and triennial) and cessation ages (75, 80, 85, and no upper age limit). We will consider two approaches to improve the treatment of breast cancer: (a) better dissemination of prevailing treatments through the use of risk assessment tools and (b) adoption of newly approved efficacious treatments. The base case scenario of treatment dissemination will be based on the actual population-based treatment pattern of older women diagnosed with breast cancer as observed in the SEER- Medicare database. We will extend a previously developed microsimulation model to conduct the proposed cost-effectiveness and budgetary impact analyses. To make the findings of our study directly applicable to decision makers at the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS), the study perspective will be that of Medicare. The benefit associated with each screening mammography strategy will be measured by the life-years saved and the quality-adjusted life-years gained. Costs to be estimated in the proposed study include those of the interventions, management of adverse events, breast cancer treatments after diagnosis, etc. The focus on old women will allow us to evaluate Medicare's current coverage of screening mammography and provide information to policy makers at the CMS to understand the clinical as well as economic benefits and risks associated with various combinations of screening and treatment patterns. Findings from our study will facilitate health policy recommendations of effective and cost-effective secondary prevention strategies and provide guidance on how to allocate the limited resource for an affordable and sustainable health care system.

Public Health Relevance

Advances in treatment may change the cost-effectiveness of secondary prevention strategies. The proposed study uses screening mammography in older women to exemplify the association between technology diffusion of breast cancer treatment and the cost-effectiveness of various strategies of screening mammography. Such information is extremely important to facilitate policy based on a clear understanding of the possible tradeoff between allocating resources to improve treatment dissemination and increasing the use of secondary prevention. This will inform policy decisions as to the best use of our limited health care resources.

National Institute of Health (NIH)
National Cancer Institute (NCI)
Exploratory/Developmental Grants (R21)
Project #
Application #
Study Section
Special Emphasis Panel (ZRG1-HDM-C (50))
Program Officer
Breen, Nancy
Project Start
Project End
Budget Start
Budget End
Support Year
Fiscal Year
Total Cost
Indirect Cost
University of Texas MD Anderson Cancer Center
Biostatistics & Other Math Sci
Other Domestic Higher Education
United States
Zip Code
Shih, Ya-Chen Tina; Xu, Ying; Dong, Wenli et al. (2014) First do no harm: population-based study shows non-evidence-based trastuzumab prescription may harm elderly women with breast cancer. Breast Cancer Res Treat 144:417-25
Carter, Stacey C; Lipsitz, Stuart; Shih, Ya-Chen T et al. (2014) Population-based determinants of radical prostatectomy operative time. BJU Int 113:E112-8
Jagsi, Reshma; Bekelman, Justin E; Chen, Aileen et al. (2014) Considerations for observational research using large data sets in radiation oncology. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys 90:11-24
Ahern, C H; Shih, Y-C T; Dong, W et al. (2014) Cost-effectiveness of alternative strategies for integrating MRI into breast cancer screening for women at high risk. Br J Cancer 111:1542-51
Brewster, Abenaa M; Bedrosian, Isabelle; Parker, Patricia A et al. (2012) Association between contralateral prophylactic mastectomy and breast cancer outcomes by hormone receptor status. Cancer 118:5637-43
Smith, Grace L; Xu, Ying; Buchholz, Thomas A et al. (2012) Association between treatment with brachytherapy vs whole-breast irradiation and subsequent mastectomy, complications, and survival among older women with invasive breast cancer. JAMA 307:1827-37