Live virus vaccines offer some of the biggest successes of medicine. They offer superior immunogenicity over inactivated virus vaccines, but they have two drawbacks. First, methods for creating attenuated vaccines are hit-and-miss. Second, successful live-virus vaccines can often evolve back to high virulence. Indeed, polio eradication has remained elusive because of vaccine evolution. The first of these hurdles is potentially surmountable with genome engineering, if we can predict the viral fitness effect of the engineering. The second hurdle may also be overcome by engineering if we understand the molecular evolution of engineered viruses. This proposal develops a combined empirical and computational viral system to study attenuation of evolutionary reversal of that attenuation. The virus is a dsDNA bacteriophage (T7) that is safe, easily manipulated and engineered. With its extensive background of genetic, biochemical and evolutionary studies, it offers the best empirical and theoretical foundation of all viruses for addressing this problem. Our approach consists of three Aims that collectively combine genome engineering with molecular studies of the viral life cycle, fitness measures, evolution of attenuated genomes, sequence analysis, and computational modeling.
In Aim 1, we build several genomes to test new methods of viral attenuation: silent codon modification, genome rearrangement, and promoter deletion. Two questions motivating this work are (i) whether the level of attenuation is predictable, and (ii) whether the attenuation is evolutionarily stable against reversion to high fit- ness. Beyond genome construction, we will thus measure fitness of all constructs and evolve all constructs for hundreds to thousands of generations, observing fitness recovery and sequence evolution.
This Aim stems from a variety of preliminary work demonstrating feasibility of all technical aspects and is the foundation of Aims 2 and 3.
Aim 2 is the application of key molecular assays to the viruses from Aim 1, proteomics, transcriptomics, and RNA densities on ribosomes (ribosomal profiling). The intracellular viral life cycle will be described at the level of transcription, translation, and protein abundance to understand the molecular bases of different attenuation methods and the paths of evolutionary recovery. Initially, we will compare patterns transcript and protein abundances with ribosome densities on mRNAs to determine whether they agree with each other and match expectations from the basic biology of the virus. Unexpected patterns will be confirmed experimentally. These methods will provide insight to how the different engineering methods attenuate and how they retard evolutionary recovery. Further, these methods will be used to parameterize and further develop an existing virtual model that gives an overall predictive framework for attenuation and evolution (Aim 3).
Aim 3 consists of modeling and analysis. Initially, an existing, second-generation computational model of the viral life cycle will be calibrated to the data we obtain for wt and attenuated viruses. As the model incorporates transcription and translation, the molecular data obtained will be compared at a mechanistic level to model predictions. We expect that translation is modeled with insufficient detail in the current model, and we will develop a third-generation model that addresses the shortcomings of the current model. Ultimately, the model we are developing will be useful for prediction of both attenuation and evolution of T7.
Vaccines remain the primary means to reduce the incidence of viral infectious diseases. A highly successful strategy to develop novel vaccines is to attenuate live viruses. However, when such attenuated viruses are administered as vaccines they often revert to more virulent forms and cause subsequent disease; a widely- known example of this effect if vaccine-derived poliovirus. This project will investigate how to attenuate viruses by transcriptional and translational de-optimization, and how to minimize an attenuated virus's ability to recover fitness.
| Paff, Matthew L; Jack, Benjamin R; Smith, Bartram L et al. (2018) Combinatorial Approaches to Viral Attenuation. mSystems 3: |
| Garry, Daniel J; Ellington, Andrew D; Molineux, Ian J et al. (2018) Viral attenuation by engineered protein fragmentation. Virus Evol 4:vey017 |
| Bull, James J; Christensen, Kelly A; Scott, Carly et al. (2018) Phage-Bacterial Dynamics with Spatial Structure: Self Organization around Phage Sinks Can Promote Increased Cell Densities. Antibiotics (Basel) 7: |
| Jiang, Qian; Teufel, Ashley I; Jackson, Eleisha L et al. (2018) Beyond Thermodynamic Constraints: Evolutionary Sampling Generates Realistic Protein Sequence Variation. Genetics 208:1387-1395 |
| Hockenberry, Adam J; Jewett, Michael C; Amaral, Luís A N et al. (2018) Within-Gene Shine-Dalgarno Sequences Are Not Selected for Function. Mol Biol Evol 35:2487-2498 |
| Tom, Eric F; Molineux, Ian J; Paff, Matthew L et al. (2018) Experimental evolution of UV resistance in a phage. PeerJ 6:e5190 |
| Smith, Bartram L; Chen, Guifang; Wilke, Claus O et al. (2018) Avian Influenza Virus PB1 Gene in H3N2 Viruses Evolved in Humans To Reduce Interferon Inhibition by Skewing Codon Usage toward Interferon-Altered tRNA Pools. MBio 9: |
| Bull, James J; Barrick, Jeffrey E (2017) Arresting Evolution. Trends Genet 33:910-920 |
| Sydykova, Dariya K; Jack, Benjamin R; Spielman, Stephanie J et al. (2017) Measuring evolutionary rates of proteins in a structural context. F1000Res 6:1845 |
| Echave, Julian; Wilke, Claus O (2017) Biophysical Models of Protein Evolution: Understanding the Patterns of Evolutionary Sequence Divergence. Annu Rev Biophys 46:85-103 |
Showing the most recent 10 out of 63 publications
