Clinical applications of reinforcement-based treatments for problem behavior in persons with intellectual and developmental disabilities reduce the frequency of problem behavior by reinforcing an explicit desirable alternative (DRA), making reinforcers contingent on the absence of problem behavior (DRO), or providing reinforcers independently of responding (NCR). Although these methods can be highly effective in reducing the frequency of problem behavior to low levels within the treatment context, they can also have the perverse effect of increasing the persistence of problem behavior if some aspect of the context is altered or if lapses in treatment integrity occur. This clinically problematic outcome is predicted by behavioral momentum theory, which proposes that the frequency and persistence of behavior are separately determined by response-reinforcer contingencies such as DRA, DRO, or NCR, and by the overall rate of reinforcers obtained in the setting (which is increased by presenting alternative reinforcers according to any contingency). This project will evaluate the extent to which different contingencies for presenting alternative reinforcers (Specific Aim 1) and the rate of alternative reinforcers (Specific Aim 2) contribute to the persistence of problem behavior. In addition, it will develop methods that may reduce the persistence of problem behavior by arranging that desirable alternative behavior is reinforced in a separate setting, elements of which may then be brought into the treatment setting to reduce the frequency of problem behavior (Specific Aim 3), or by making access to that separate setting contingent on the absence of problem behavior (Specific Aim 4). Studies addressing each of these aims will be conducted with animal subjects in controlled experimental conditions modeled on those in which basic research on behavioral momentum originated. These studies will be repeated with children with intellectual and developmental disabilities in translational settings employing arbitrary responses analogous to problem and alternative behavior to ensure applicability of the animal data to the clinical population. Clinical interventions addressing significant problem behavior in children with intellectual and developmental disabilities will apply the most effective methods identified in basic and translational studies. Coordination of these studies within a single research project and the integration of their findings across the full range from basic research to clinical application will contribute importantly to effective treatment.

Public Health Relevance

The proposed research is highly relevant to the public health interests of NICHD and its Mental Retardation Developmental Disabilities Branch. A significant proportion of individuals with intellectual and developmental disabilities receive reinforcer-based behavioral interventions to reduce the frequency of problem behaviors. The proposed project will (a) determine conditions under which such interventions also have the unintended side effect of increasing the persistence of those problem behaviors, and (b) contribute to the development of alternative treatment strategies that circumvent this side effect.

National Institute of Health (NIH)
Eunice Kennedy Shriver National Institute of Child Health & Human Development (NICHD)
Research Project (R01)
Project #
Application #
Study Section
Special Emphasis Panel (ZRG1-BBBP-S (03))
Program Officer
Kau, Alice S
Project Start
Project End
Budget Start
Budget End
Support Year
Fiscal Year
Total Cost
Indirect Cost
University of New Hampshire
Schools of Arts and Sciences
United States
Zip Code
Craig, Andrew R; Cunningham, Paul J; Sweeney, Mary M et al. (2018) Delivering alternative reinforcement in a distinct context reduces its counter-therapeutic effects on relapse. J Exp Anal Behav 109:492-505
Dube, William V; Thompson, Brooks; Silveira, Marcelo V et al. (2017) The Role of Contingencies and Stimuli in a Human Laboratory Model of Treatment of Problem Behavior. Psychol Rec 67:463-471
Nevin, John A; Craig, Andrew R; Cunningham, Paul J et al. (2017) Quantitative models of persistence and relapse from the perspective of behavioral momentum theory: Fits and misfits. Behav Processes 141:92-99
Sweeney, Mary M; Shahan, Timothy A (2016) Resurgence of target responding does not exceed increases in inactive responding in a forced-choice alternative reinforcement procedure in humans. Behav Processes 124:80-92
Nevin, John A; Mace, F Charles; DeLeon, Iser G et al. (2016) Effects of signaled and unsignaled alternative reinforcement on persistence and relapse in children and pigeons. J Exp Anal Behav 106:34-57
Craig, Andrew R; Cunningham, Paul J; Shahan, Timothy A (2015) Behavioral momentum and accumulation of mass in multiple schedules. J Exp Anal Behav 103:437-49
Sweeney, Mary M; Shahan, Timothy A (2015) Renewal, resurgence, and alternative reinforcement context. Behav Processes 116:43-9
Shahan, Timothy A; Craig, Andrew R; Sweeney, Mary M (2015) Resurgence of sucrose and cocaine seeking in free-feeding rats. Behav Brain Res 279:47-51
Sweeney, Mary M; Moore, Keira; Shahan, Timothy A et al. (2014) Modeling the effects of sensory reinforcers on behavioral persistence with alternative reinforcement. J Exp Anal Behav 102:252-66
Pritchard, Duncan; Hoerger, Marguerite; Mace, F Charles (2014) Treatment relapse and behavioral momentum theory. J Appl Behav Anal 47:814-33

Showing the most recent 10 out of 16 publications