Increasing the number of African American (AA) women who are diagnosed with breast cancer at early stages is a public health priority. Patient navigation has been developed to address this problem and is increasingly widespread in public health practice. This individual-level strategy may have greater impacts than have been previously estimated. Based on diffusion of innovation theories and our previous research, we hypothesize that navigation may indirectly benefit patients' female relatives and non-relative friends (?alters?) and, subsequently, population-level stage at diagnosis. Briefly, navigators coordinate care and provide informational, emotional, and logistic support to patients. Receiving these additional supports has been associated with greater breast cancer knowledge, medical system trust/knowledge, and breast cancer-specific communication self-efficacy among navigated women. Empowering breast cancer patients through navigation may manifest in greater survivor-driven dissemination to individuals known pre-diagnosis (induction). Survivors may also have greater motivation to engage new individuals as a breast cancer leader (node addition, key network position). These network changes and greater dissemination may result in greater rates of breast cancer-related shared decision making practices, risk assessment, and screening among the alters of navigated women compared to alters of non-navigated women. This may result in improved stage at diagnosis at the population-level. Including network effects in economic evaluations may also reveal lower incremental costs for implementing patient navigation than previously estimated. We will leverage system science methodologies (social network analysis, agent-based modeling) to test these hypotheses and model how patient navigation may inadvertently improve the likelihood of early stage diagnoses at the population-level.
In Aim 1, we will recruit AA breast cancer patients from a completed, NIH-funded randomized controlled trial in South Chicago to compare patterns of breast cancer communication among 50 navigated and 50 non-navigated women using standard egocentric network instruments. The primary outcomes will be the number of women to whom AA breast cancer patients initiated conversations about breast cancer and the frequency of these conversations. Next, we will compare breast cancer care among 150 family and friends identified by navigated and non-navigated women. The primary outcomes will be breast cancer-related shared decision making practices with primary care providers, risk assessment (genetic counseling, genetic testing), and breast cancer screening uptake. Finally, we will determine the incremental costs of navigation compared to standard care for each additional stage at diagnosis (including patients and their family/friends).
In Aim 2, we will use published literature and other local data sources to model improved population-level breast health as an emergent property from one agent (the breast cancer patient) to other agents (relative/non-relative) using an agent-based model that incorporates biological, intrapersonal, interpersonal, and network-level characteristics.

Public Health Relevance

This development proposal will assess if patient navigation has unintended benefits for the populations in which patients are embedded and to estimate its cost-effectiveness when including such benefits. First, we will examine if: 1) navigation led patients to share information more often and to more individuals than standard care among 100 African American breast cancer patients from a completed trial; 2) navigation thus resulted in greater breast cancer care use among 150 screening-eligible women within patients' networks; and, 3) cost effectiveness of navigation is greater, when accounting for the indirect effects on women in participants' networks in addition to its direct effects on participants. Second, we will model how navigation may lead to population-level improvement in stage at diagnosis through 3 network mechanisms (i.e., navigation results in increased, sustained communication; larger networks; more pivotal network positions for navigated women) and how effects vary depending on distribution of networks' breast cancer risk.

National Institute of Health (NIH)
National Cancer Institute (NCI)
Exploratory/Developmental Grants (R21)
Project #
Application #
Study Section
Special Emphasis Panel (ZRG1)
Program Officer
Breslau, Erica S
Project Start
Project End
Budget Start
Budget End
Support Year
Fiscal Year
Total Cost
Indirect Cost
University of Illinois at Chicago
Public Health & Prev Medicine
Schools of Public Health
United States
Zip Code