Noninvasive prenatal genetic testing (NIPT) is revolutionizing the practice of obstetrics. However, the technol- ogy is expanding rapidly and in a way that has outpaced the rate at which evidence-based strategies for its in- tegration can be developed and implemented. Initially, NIPT was used as a screen for a limited number of an- euploidies and genetic conditions. Now, it is possible to confer information about numerous other fetal genetic conditions with variable phenotypic severity never before a part of prenatal screening as well as providing in- formation about markers that have undetermined significance. In addition, information gained from NIPT may have unexpected consequences by identifying maternal or paternal factors that may be unwanted or unex- pected. Thus, the decision-making process for NIPT is uniquely complex. An urgent clinical problem has emerged: there is a lack of evidence-based tools to guide OB providers in effective and patient-centered edu- cation and decision support for NIPT. The magnitude of this problem becomes evident when considering that over four million women receive prenatal care in the U.S. annually and there are not enough prenatal genet- ic counselors or maternal-fetal medicine specialists to meet this demand, particularly in rural and urban set- tings that already face poorer obstetric outcomes due to barriers in access prenatal care. The primary goal of this study is to ensure that all patients have informed access to NIPT by means of an effective communica- tion tool reflecting the perspectives of patients, partners, and OB providers designed to support patients? informed decision-making about its use. Our central hypothesis is that, by focusing on the dynamic interac- tion between the patient and provider, the use of an evidence-based communication tool will result in a shared decision-making process that, in turn, will increase patients? ability to make an informed choice about NIPT and decrease patients? decisional conflict. We will examine this hypothesis using an evidence- based communication tool and a series of validated quantitative measures combined with in-depth interviews with key stakeholders in the NIPT translation process. This project is innovative because it will provide a new framework for the informed decision-making process that focuses on the patient and provider as dyads in the informed decision-making process. This work is significant because, once this point-of-care intervention is available, it will help expectant parents have informed access to advances in prenatal genetic tests that use next generation sequencing technologies. These results are expected to have an important positive impact on public health, as informed access to advances in genetic technologies is not only foundational to the ethical practice of medicine but also a key component of quality, access, and outcomes of personalized medicine. We anticipate that this study?s findings will ultimately contribute to empowering pregnant women and their partners to make informed choices that reflect their needs and preferences as individuals and parents.

Public Health Relevance

The goal of this study is to study the effect of an evidence-based communication tool to support patients? decision-making about noninvasive prenatal genetic testing, by focusing on the communication that takes place in the clinical encounter. By doing so, we will also identify in the patient-provider interaction aspects that are key to implementing effective strategies responsive to the challenges posed by the continued development of NIPT involving new applications of sequencing technology that dramatically increase the volume and complexity of information available to expectant parents about the developing fetus. This project is relevant to public health because informed decision-making is not only a part of patient quality and safety initiatives but also a crucial step in the translational process that brings advances in obstetric and genetic science from the bench to the bedside.

Agency
National Institute of Health (NIH)
Institute
National Human Genome Research Institute (NHGRI)
Type
Research Project (R01)
Project #
5R01HG010092-03
Application #
9751355
Study Section
Societal and Ethical Issues in Research Study Section (SEIR)
Program Officer
Boyer, Joy
Project Start
2017-09-14
Project End
2021-06-30
Budget Start
2019-07-01
Budget End
2020-06-30
Support Year
3
Fiscal Year
2019
Total Cost
Indirect Cost
Name
Cleveland Clinic Lerner
Department
Surgery
Type
Schools of Medicine
DUNS #
135781701
City
Cleveland
State
OH
Country
United States
Zip Code
44195